Logo for HistoryGap

Characters Characters

Kenneth "Kenny" O'Donnell

Bad portrayal
Special Assistant to JFK, Narrator

Based on the real Kenneth O'Donnell, but his role is vastly inflated in the film. Historical accounts and participants confirm O'Donnell was not a central advisor or key player during the missile crisis as depicted by Kevin Costner.

President John F. Kennedy

Historic
U.S. President

Based on the real JFK. Bruce Greenwood's portrayal captures Kennedy's measured demeanor, stress, and decision-making process during the crisis, broadly aligning with historical records like the ExComm tapes.

Robert F. Kennedy

Historic
Attorney General, JFK's brother

Based on the real RFK. Steven Culp portrays his crucial role as a close advisor to the President and key negotiator in backchannel talks with the Soviet ambassador, which is historically accurate.

Robert McNamara

Historic
Secretary of Defense

Based on the real Robert McNamara. Dylan Baker portrays his role within ExComm, initially leaning towards military options but ultimately supporting the blockade and diplomacy, consistent with historical accounts.

McGeorge Bundy

Historic
National Security Advisor

Based on the real McGeorge Bundy, accurately shown as a key member of the ExComm advisory group during the crisis.

Dean Rusk

Historic
Secretary of State

Based on the real Dean Rusk, shown participating in ExComm debates, generally reflecting his historical role.

More characters

Adlai Stevenson

Historic
U.S. Ambassador to the UN

Based on the real Adlai Stevenson. His confrontation with the Soviet ambassador at the UN Security Council is accurately depicted based on historical footage and accounts.

Gen. Curtis LeMay

Bad portrayal
Air Force Chief of Staff

Based on the real Curtis LeMay. Kevin Conway's portrayal emphasizes his extremely hawkish stance, representing the military pressure for an air strike/invasion. Critics argue the portrayal is an overly aggressive caricature.

Gen. Maxwell Taylor

Partly historic
Chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff

Based on the real Maxwell Taylor. Bill Smitrovich portrays him representing the Joint Chiefs' perspective favouring military action. While reflecting military advice, the film might oversimplify or stereotype his position.

John McCone

Historic
Director of Central Intelligence

Based on the real John McCone, head of the CIA, accurately shown presenting intelligence findings (like U-2 photos) to ExComm.

Dean Acheson

Historic
Former Sec. of State, Advisor

Based on the real Dean Acheson, brought in as an experienced advisor, accurately depicted advocating strongly for military action (air strike).

Theodore "Ted" Sorensen

Historic
Special Counsel to JFK

Based on the real Ted Sorensen, Kennedy's speechwriter and close advisor, accurately shown participating in ExComm discussions.

Cmdr. William B. Ecker

Historic
Reconnaissance Pilot

Based on the real U.S. Navy pilot who flew low-level reconnaissance missions over Cuba. The film depicts these dangerous missions.

Major Rudolf Anderson, Jr.

Historic
U-2 Pilot

Based on the real U.S. Air Force pilot whose U-2 spy plane was shot down over Cuba during the crisis, a major escalation accurately depicted.

Pierre Salinger

Historic
White House Press Secretary

Based on the real Pierre Salinger, accurately shown being largely kept out of the loop during the initial days of the crisis.

Story Story

Discovery of Soviet missiles in Cuba (Oct 1962)

True

U-2 spy planes discovering Soviet nuclear missile sites under construction in Cuba was the event that triggered the crisis, accurately depicted as the film's starting point.

Formation of ExComm / Secret meetings

True

President Kennedy did convene a secret group of advisors (Executive Committee of the National Security Council - ExComm) to manage the crisis, as shown. The film draws dialogue from actual tapes of these meetings.

ExComm debates: Blockade vs. Air Strike/Invasion

True

The intense internal debates within ExComm over the appropriate response – primarily between establishing a naval quarantine (blockade) or launching military action – are historically accurate.

O'Donnell as central White House coordinator

False

The film portrays Kenny O'Donnell as a primary advisor, negotiator, and conduit between JFK, RFK, and the military. Historical sources and participants state O'Donnell played a very minor role in the crisis.

JFK's televised address announcing missiles/quarantine

True

President Kennedy's dramatic televised speech to the nation on October 22, 1962, revealing the missiles and announcing the naval quarantine, is accurately depicted.

Implementation of naval quarantine ("blockade")

True

The U.S. Navy establishing the quarantine line around Cuba to intercept Soviet ships is accurately portrayed as the chosen initial response.

Low-level reconnaissance flights over Cuba

True

The US conducted dangerous low-altitude photo reconnaissance flights (RF-8 Crusaders, F-101 Voodoos) to get clearer images of the missile sites, accurately shown being fired upon.

U-2 spy plane shot down over Cuba

True

The shooting down of Major Rudolf Anderson's U-2 on October 27, 1962, significantly escalated tensions and increased pressure for military action, as accurately depicted.

Backchannel negotiations (RFK and Dobrynin)

True

Secret negotiations between Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy and Soviet Ambassador Anatoly Dobrynin were crucial to finding a peaceful resolution, as depicted.

Secret deal to remove US missiles from Turkey

Partly true

A secret agreement to remove US Jupiter missiles from Turkey was part of the resolution. The film depicts this being shared broadly within ExComm; historically, knowledge of this quid pro quo was kept extremely limited (primarily the Kennedy brothers, Rusk, possibly McNamara).

Portrayal of Military Leaders (JCS)

Bad depiction

The film depicts the Joint Chiefs of Staff (especially LeMay and Taylor) as almost uniformly aggressive, advocating strongly for immediate military action and potentially trying to manoeuvre the President. Historians argue this is a simplification/caricature, although military pressure was real.

O'Donnell directly influences/instructs pilots

False

Scenes showing O'Donnell directly communicating with or giving instructions/advice to reconnaissance pilots (like telling Ecker to lie about being shot at) are fictional inventions to enhance his character's role.

Khrushchev agrees to remove missiles from Cuba

True

The Soviet Premier agreeing to dismantle and remove the offensive missiles from Cuba in exchange for a US non-invasion pledge (and the secret Turkey missile deal) was the core of the crisis resolution.

Avoidance of nuclear war

True

The successful diplomatic resolution prevented a potential nuclear exchange between the US and USSR, accurately portrayed as the outcome of the thirteen days.

Setting Setting

White House interiors (Oval Office, Cabinet Room)

Good depiction

The film meticulously recreated key White House rooms based on photographs and records from 1962, providing an authentic backdrop for the ExComm meetings and presidential decisions.

Washington D.C. atmosphere (October 1962)

Good depiction

Captures the tension and gravity of the crisis period in the US capital, showing government buildings, military presence, and a sense of impending conflict.

Military settings (Pentagon, air bases, ships)

Good depiction

Represents various military environments accurately, including command centers, Strategic Air Command readiness, naval operations for the quarantine, and reconnaissance aircraft/airfields.

United Nations Security Council chamber

Good depiction

The setting for Adlai Stevenson's famous confrontation with the Soviet ambassador is accurately depicted.

Period costumes, props, vehicles (1962)

Good depiction

Clothing styles (suits, military uniforms, civilian dress), cars, office equipment, military hardware (planes, ships), and other props accurately reflect the early 1960s timeframe.

Use of black-and-white "archival" segments

Average depiction

The film intersperses color scenes with black-and-white segments, sometimes meant to evoke news footage. Critics noted this stylistic choice was used somewhat inconsistently and didn't always enhance realism.

Atmosphere of Cold War tension / Nuclear brink

Good depiction

Effectively conveys the extreme tension, uncertainty, and palpable fear of imminent nuclear war that characterized the Cuban Missile Crisis.