Historical accuracy of The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc

Historical accuracy of The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc

Characters
Joan of Arc
Based on the real Joan of Arc. While key life events align, the film's portrayal (Milla Jovovich) emphasizes psychological trauma (fictional sister's rape/murder) as motivation and depicts visions ambiguously, differing significantly from historical accounts and Joan's own testimony of divine guidance. Her demeanor is portrayed as more erratic and manic than described by contemporaries.
Charles VII
Based on the real Charles VII. Malkovich's portrayal depicts him as older, more cynical, manipulative, and physically capable than the historical Dauphin, who was younger (26 when he met Joan), physically unimpressive, pious, and known for indecisiveness but not overt betrayal depicted.
Yolande of Aragon
Based on the real Yolande of Aragon, a powerful political figure. The film depicts her influence and initial support for Joan, which is historically plausible, though her specific characterization and actions are interpreted dramatically.
The Conscience
A completely allegorical/fictional character played by Dustin Hoffman, representing Joan's internal doubts or a modern psychological interpretation of her experiences. This figure does not exist in historical accounts of her imprisonment or trial.
Gilles de Rais
Based on the real Gilles de Rais who fought alongside Joan. The film depicts him as a loyal but perhaps brutal soldier. His later infamous crimes as a serial killer are not part of the film's scope.
Jean de Dunois
Based on the real Jean de Dunois, a key commander who fought with Joan at Orléans and other campaigns. His military role alongside Joan is accurately represented.
More characters
La Hire
Based on the real Étienne de Vignolles ("La Hire"), a famously rough and effective French captain who fought alongside Joan. His presence is historically accurate.
Pierre Cauchon
Based on the real Bishop Cauchon of Beauvais who presided over Joan's trial of condemnation. His role as the lead ecclesiastical judge in the pro-English court is historically accurate.
John Talbot
Based on the real John Talbot, 1st Earl of Shrewsbury, a prominent English commander during the Hundred Years' War, present during the French campaigns involving Joan.
Jean d'Aulon
Based on the real Jean d'Aulon, appointed as Joan's squire, who accompanied her throughout her campaigns and testified at her Rehabilitation Trial.
Catherine
Joan had siblings, but the film invents an older sister named Catherine whose brutal rape and murder Joan witnesses as a child, providing a fictional psychological motivation (revenge/trauma) for Joan's actions.
Story
Joan witnesses sister's rape/murder
This traumatic childhood event is a major fabrication by the filmmakers to provide a psychological, revenge-based motivation for Joan, contrary to her stated divine mission. Her family fled before their village was attacked by Burgundians (not English).
Joan experiences visions/hears voices
Joan historically claimed to receive divine guidance from saints. The film depicts these visions ambiguously, often violently or confusingly, suggesting psychological disturbance rather than divine inspiration, a modern interpretation not supported by Joan's testimony.
Journey to Chinon / Meeting the Dauphin
Joan did travel to Chinon and famously identified the Dauphin Charles VII despite attempts to disguise him.
Examination by theologians
Joan underwent examinations by theologians at Poitiers to verify her claims and orthodoxy before being granted command, as depicted (though details are condensed).
Leading army / Relief of Siege of Orléans
Joan's arrival dramatically boosted morale, and she played a key role in lifting the English siege of Orléans in 1429, a major turning point accurately shown as her first great success.
Joan's conduct in battle / Wounded
The film portrays Joan as almost manic and bloodthirsty in battle. Contemporaries described her as courageous and inspirational, carrying her banner, but not engaging in killing; she wept for the dead on both sides. She was wounded by an arrow at Orléans, as shown.
Leading Dauphin to Coronation at Reims
Joan successfully led Charles VII through enemy territory to Reims Cathedral for his official coronation as King of France, a crucial symbolic victory.
Failed assault on Paris
Joan participated in an unsuccessful attempt to retake Paris, during which she was wounded again. The film depicts the failure and growing political tensions.
Charles VII conspires to have Joan captured
The film suggests Charles actively plotted Joan's capture. Historically, while he failed to ransom or rescue her, there's no evidence he deliberately arranged her capture by the Burgundians at Compiègne.
Capture at Compiègne / Sold to English
Joan was captured by Burgundian forces during a skirmish outside Compiègne in 1430 and later sold to the English.
Trial for heresy presided over by Cauchon
Joan faced a lengthy ecclesiastical trial for heresy dominated by pro-English clergy led by Bishop Pierre Cauchon in Rouen.
Interrogations with "The Conscience"
The scenes where Joan debates theology and her motivations with Dustin Hoffman's character are entirely fictional, representing internal doubt or a modern psychological lens.
Recantation, relapse (wearing men's clothes)
Joan did briefly sign a recantation under duress but quickly renounced it. Resuming male clothing (which English guards may have forced upon her, as the film suggests) was used as proof of her relapse into heresy.
Execution by burning at the stake (1431)
Joan of Arc was found guilty of relapsed heresy and burned at the stake in the marketplace of Rouen on May 30, 1431. The film depicts the event, though omits details like her calling Jesus's name.
Canonization mentioned in postscript
The postscript accurately notes Joan was later exonerated (Rehabilitation Trial 1456) and eventually canonized as a saint by the Catholic Church in 1920.
Setting
15th Century France (Domrémy, Orléans, etc.)
Filmed largely in the Czech Republic and France, the locations and set design effectively evoke the general atmosphere of war-torn, late-medieval France.
Hundred Years' War Context
The film establishes the backdrop of the ongoing conflict between France and England, the division of France (Armagnac vs. Burgundian factions), and the significance of Orléans.
Castles and Fortifications
Depicts impressive medieval castles (like Chinon) and fortifications (like Les Tourelles at Orléans), giving a sense of the period's architecture and siege warfare settings.
Battlefield depictions
Battle scenes are visually striking and brutal but sometimes stylized. The emphasis on graphic violence and certain tactics might prioritize cinematic impact over precise 15th-century battle realism.
Religious Settings (Churches, Trial)
Settings like village churches, Reims Cathedral (coronation), and the ecclesiastical court for the trial reflect the pervasive religious context of the era.
Costumes (Peasant, Noble, Clerical)
Costumes generally reflect the distinctions between peasant attire, noble finery, clerical robes, and military garb appropriate for the early 15th century.
Armor and Weaponry
Joan's "white armor" (full plate) is historically plausible (she was gifted armor). Other armor and weapons (swords, axes, bows, cannons - though trebuchets shown are less likely) reflect the period.
Depiction of violence/brutality
The film graphically depicts medieval warfare and cruelty (like the fictional rape/murder). While the era was brutal, the level and style might be exaggerated for modern cinematic effect.