Logo for HistoryGap

Characters Characters

Sgt. John McLoughlin

Historic
Senior PAPD officer trapped

Based on the real John McLoughlin. Nicolas Cage portrays his experience being trapped deep in the rubble after the towers collapsed. McLoughlin consulted on the film, ensuring accuracy to his experience.

Officer Will Jimeno

Historic
Younger PAPD officer trapped

Based on the real Will Jimeno. Michael Peña portrays his experience being trapped alongside McLoughlin. Jimeno also consulted on the film, ensuring accuracy to his account.

Donna McLoughlin

Historic
John McLoughlin's wife

Based on the real Donna McLoughlin. Maria Bello portrays her anguished wait for news about her husband, reflecting the real experiences of families on 9/11.

Allison Jimeno

Historic
Will Jimeno's pregnant wife

Based on the real Allison Jimeno. Maggie Gyllenhaal portrays her experience waiting for news while pregnant, accurately reflecting her situation on 9/11.

Officer Dominick Pezzulo

Historic
PAPD officer trapped, died

Based on the real Dominick Pezzulo, who was with McLoughlin and Jimeno but died from injuries sustained in the collapse shortly after. Jay Hernandez portrays his bravery.

Officer Antonio Rodrigues

Historic
PAPD officer with team

Based on the real Antonio Rodrigues, part of McLoughlin's initial PAPD team responding to the towers.

More characters

Officer Christopher Amoroso

Historic
PAPD officer with team, died

Based on the real Christopher Amoroso, another member of McLoughlin's team who died in the collapse.

Staff Sgt. Dave Karnes

Historic
U.S. Marine rescuer

Based on the real Dave Karnes, a former Marine who felt called to duty, went to Ground Zero, and was instrumental in locating McLoughlin and Jimeno. Michael Shannon portrays him.

Sgt. Jason Thomas

Historic
U.S. Marine rescuer

Based on the real Jason Thomas, another Marine who partnered with Karnes in the search and rescue effort at Ground Zero, accurately depicted finding the trapped officers.

Scott Strauss

Historic
NYPD ESU Officer (Rescuer)

Based on the real Scott Strauss, one of the specialized NYPD officers involved in the difficult extrication of McLoughlin and Jimeno.

Paddy McGee

Historic
FDNY Firefighter (Rescuer)

Based on the real Paddy McGee, one of the FDNY members involved in the rescue operation.

Chuck Sereika

Historic
Paramedic (Rescuer)

Based on the real paramedic who provided critical medical aid to the trapped officers during the long rescue process.

Story Story

PAPD officers respond to WTC attack

True

McLoughlin, Jimeno, Pezzulo and others were part of the Port Authority Police response entering the World Trade Center complex to assist with evacuation and rescue after the planes hit.

McLoughlin's team gathers rescue equipment

True

The team retrieving equipment from Building 5 before entering the concourse between the towers is accurate to McLoughlin's account.

Trapped in concourse elevator shaft by South Tower collapse

True

McLoughlin, Jimeno, and Pezzulo were in the WTC concourse near a freight elevator when the South Tower collapsed, trapping them in the debris, matching their real experience.

Pezzulo initially free, dies trying to help

True

Dominick Pezzulo survived the initial collapse relatively unpinned but was fatally injured by falling debris while trying to free Jimeno, accurately reflecting his heroic actions.

McLoughlin and Jimeno pinned deep in rubble

True

Both officers were severely pinned by concrete and steel deep beneath the rubble pile for many hours.

Experiences while trapped (conversations, visions)

Partly true

The film depicts their conversations and moments of hallucination/vision (like Jimeno seeing Jesus). While based on their recollections, specific dialogue and imagery are likely dramatized for the film.

Families wait anxiously for news

True

The depiction of Donna McLoughlin and Allison Jimeno enduring an agonizing wait, seeking information, and supporting each other accurately reflects the reality for countless families on 9/11.

Marine Dave Karnes goes to Ground Zero

True

Karnes, an accountant and Marine reservist, did feel compelled to go to Ground Zero from his office in Connecticut to assist, obtaining a uniform and gear along the way.

Karnes and Jason Thomas search rubble

True

Karnes did team up with another Marine, Jason Thomas (whose identity was unknown for years after 9/11), and they searched the perilous site calling out for survivors.

Karnes and Thomas locate McLoughlin and Jimeno

True

The two Marines heard the officers' calls for help and were the first to locate them deep within the debris field late on the night of September 11th.

Lengthy and difficult rescue/extrication operation

True

The subsequent rescue involving FDNY, NYPD ESU, paramedics and others was extremely complex, dangerous, and time-consuming (taking hours), accurately reflected in the film.

Jimeno rescued first, then McLoughlin

True

Will Jimeno was extricated after about 13 hours trapped; John McLoughlin, buried deeper, was rescued after approximately 22 hours.

Focus on survival and rescue, not politics/attackers

Good depiction

The film deliberately avoids focusing on the attackers or the political context, centering tightly on the human story of survival, rescue, and family support, as intended by the filmmakers and survivors.

Physical injuries sustained by officers

True

The film accurately portrays the severe, life-threatening injuries (crush injuries, compartment syndrome) sustained by both McLoughlin and Jimeno, requiring extensive surgeries and rehabilitation.

Setting Setting

World Trade Center Complex (Pre-Collapse)

Good depiction

Briefly shows the WTC concourse and lobby areas before the collapses, recreating the environment where the officers were operating.

Ground Zero Rubble Pile (Post-Collapse)

Good depiction

The film uses detailed sets and effects to realistically portray the dangerous, chaotic, and vast debris field of Ground Zero where the officers were trapped and the rescue took place.

New York City Atmosphere on 9/11

Good depiction

Captures the shock, confusion, dust-filled air, and emergency response mobilization throughout the city immediately following the attacks.

Time Period (September 11-12, 2001)

True

The film accurately focuses on the events unfolding during the day of the attacks and the immediate rescue period over the following day.

PAPD, FDNY, NYPD Presence

Good depiction

Accurately shows the massive, coordinated (though initially chaotic) response of various NYC first responder agencies at Ground Zero, highlighting inter-agency cooperation during the rescue efforts.

Uniforms and Equipment

Good depiction

Portrays accurate uniforms and equipment used by PAPD, FDNY, NYPD ESU personnel, and the Marines involved in the rescue, as well as period-appropriate civilian clothing.

Hospital / Family Waiting Areas

Good depiction

Realistically depicts the stressful environments where families gathered awaiting news and where survivors received medical treatment.