Logo for HistoryGap

Characters Characters

Wyatt Earp

Partly historic
Stoic former lawman seeking peace

Earp was a real figure in Tombstone. The film captures his leadership role and involvement in events accurately, but simplifies his motivations and likely presents a more heroic version than the complex historical man.

Doc Holliday

Partly historic
Dapper, deadly gambler/dentist with TB

Holliday was Earp's real friend. Val Kilmer's portrayal is widely praised for capturing Holliday's documented Southern manners, wit, loyalty, worsening illness, and deadly reputation. Much dialogue is based on reported quotes.

Virgil Earp

Historic
Wyatt's older brother, Tombstone City Marshal

Virgil was the City Marshal and played a key role in the events leading up to and including the O.K. Corral gunfight. His wounding is accurately depicted.

Morgan Earp

Historic
Wyatt's younger brother, deputy

Morgan served as a deputy under Virgil and was involved in the gunfight. His subsequent assassination is historically accurate.

Josephine Marcus

Partly historic
Actress, Wyatt's eventual love interest

Josephine Marcus was a real figure who became Wyatt Earp's long-term common-law wife. The film depicts her presence and relationship with Wyatt, though the timeline and details of her prior involvement with Behan are simplified/dramatized.

Johnny Ringo

Partly historic
Educated, melancholic Cowboy outlaw

Ringo was a real outlaw associated with the Cowboys. His reputation for being educated and dangerous is noted historically. His rivalry with Holliday and manner of death are heavily fictionalized in the film.

More characters

Curly Bill Brocius

Historic
Leader of the Cowboys faction

William "Curly Bill" Brocius was a real and prominent outlaw leader in the Tombstone area. His shooting of Marshal Fred White is based on a real incident (though details vary).

Ike Clanton

Historic
Boastful, threatening Cowboy

Ike Clanton's drunken threats against the Earps were a key factor leading to the O.K. Corral gunfight. His cowardice during the fight (running away) is also historically accurate.

Billy Clanton

Historic
Ike's younger brother

Billy Clanton was involved in the gunfight and was killed.

Frank McLaury

Historic
Cowboy killed at O.K. Corral

Frank McLaury was involved in the gunfight and was killed.

Tom McLaury

Historic
Cowboy killed at O.K. Corral

Tom McLaury was involved in the gunfight and was killed.

Johnny Behan

Historic
Cochise County Sheriff, Earp rival

Behan was the County Sheriff, often at odds with the Earps (who represented city policing/interests). His attempts to disarm the Earps before the gunfight and perceived siding with the Cowboys align with historical accounts.

Sherman McMasters

Historic
Earp posse member, former Cowboy

McMasters was a real figure who rode with the Earp posse during the Vendetta Ride.

Turkey Creek Jack Johnson

Historic
Earp posse member

Johnson was a real member of the Earp Vendetta Ride posse.

Texas Jack Vermillion

Historic
Earp posse member

Vermillion was a real member of the Earp Vendetta Ride posse.

Story Story

Earps arrive in Tombstone seeking business opportunities/peace

True

The Earp brothers did come to the booming mining town of Tombstone seeking financial opportunities, initially not intending to wear badges again.

Conflict between Earps/town faction and Cowboys

True

Real tensions existed between the Earp brothers (and town business interests) and the Clanton-McLaury faction ("Cowboys") involved in rural ranching and suspected rustling/violence.

Curly Bill shooting Marshal Fred White

True

Curly Bill did accidentally shoot and kill Marshal White in 1880. Wyatt Earp arrested him; the incident increased tensions but was generally ruled accidental at the time.

Ike Clanton's threats preceding the gunfight

True

Ike Clanton spent the night before the gunfight drinking heavily and making loud public threats against the Earps and Holliday.

The Gunfight at the O.K. Corral (Oct 26, 1881)

Partly true

The core event occurred, resulting in three deaths (True). It happened in a vacant lot near Fremont St, beside Fly's photo studio, not directly in the O.K. Corral (Partly true on location name/accuracy). Specific movements/shots are dramatized.

Deaths of Billy Clanton, Frank & Tom McLaury

True

These three Cowboys were killed during the brief, intense gunfight.

Virgil and Morgan Earp wounded in gunfight

True

Both Virgil and Morgan sustained wounds during the O.K. Corral gunfight.

Ambush and crippling of Virgil Earp

True

In December 1881, Virgil was ambushed and shot, severely wounding his left arm, effectively crippling it.

Assassination of Morgan Earp

True

In March 1882, Morgan Earp was shot in the back and killed while playing billiards, escalating the conflict.

Wyatt Earp forming federal posse (Earp Vendetta Ride)

True

After Morgan's murder, Wyatt Earp (acting with debatable legal authority via federal deputization) formed a posse including Holliday and others to hunt down those they believed responsible.

Killing Frank Stilwell at Tucson station

True

Wyatt Earp and his posse encountered Frank Stilwell (a suspect in Morgan's murder) at the Tucson train station and killed him.

Vendetta Ride pursuit and killings (Curly Bill, Barnes etc.)

Partly true

The posse did track and kill several other men associated with the Cowboys, including Curly Bill Brocius (at Iron Springs). Specific details of these encounters are often unclear historically and dramatized.

Doc Holliday participating in Vendetta Ride

True

Despite his worsening tuberculosis, Doc Holliday did ride with Wyatt Earp during the Vendetta Ride.

Doc Holliday vs. Johnny Ringo duel

False

This iconic standoff is completely fictional. Johnny Ringo died later (July 1882), most likely by suicide, though the exact circumstances are debated. There was no known duel between him and Holliday.

Development of Wyatt Earp / Josephine Marcus relationship

Partly true

Wyatt and Josephine did become a couple, eventually living together for decades. The film depicts the beginning of their relationship amidst the Tombstone turmoil, simplifying the timeline.

Setting Setting

Tombstone, Arizona Territory (c. 1881-1882)

True

The film is accurately set in the famous silver mining boomtown during the peak of its notoriety.

Appearance of Tombstone town

Good depiction

The film's sets and locations effectively recreate the dusty streets, wooden buildings, saloons (like the Crystal Palace), and bustling atmosphere of a prosperous frontier mining town.

Arizona landscape

Good depiction

Filmed primarily in Arizona, the movie accurately captures the distinctive Southwestern desert environment surrounding Tombstone.

Fashion (Western & Victorian)

Good depiction

Costumes accurately reflect the period: practical Western wear for cowboys/lawmen, more formal suits for town figures, and Victorian-era dresses for women like Josephine.

Weaponry (Colt Peacemaker, Winchester rifle, shotgun etc.)

Good depiction

Firearms depicted, particularly the Colt Single Action Army revolver ("Peacemaker"), Winchester repeating rifles, and shotguns (like Doc's Meteor shotgun), are iconic and period-accurate.

Transportation (Horses, stagecoach, train)

Good depiction

Accurately shows horses as the primary mode of transport, along with stagecoaches for longer travel and the arrival of the railroad in nearby towns like Tucson.

Saloons, Gambling, Entertainment (Bird Cage Theatre)

Good depiction

Recreates the prominent role of saloons for socializing and gambling. Features the real Bird Cage Theatre, known for its rough entertainment.

Law Enforcement structure (City Marshal vs. County Sheriff)

True

Accurately reflects the jurisdictional distinctions and potential conflicts between the Town Marshal (Virgil Earp) responsible for the city and the County Sheriff (Johnny Behan).

Atmosphere of the "Wild West"

Good depiction

Captures the legendary frontier atmosphere: a mix of rapid growth, opportunity, rough justice, sudden violence, and the tension between established order and lawlessness.

O.K. Corral / Fremont Street area

Good depiction

While the fight wasn't in the corral itself, the film depicts the general area near Fremont Street accurately enough to convey the setting of the famous gunfight.