Logo for HistoryGap

Characters Characters

Amsterdam Vallon

False
Leonardo DiCaprio

Amsterdam Vallon is a fictional character.

William "Bill the Butcher" Cutting

Partly historic
Ruthless gang leader

Bill the Butcher is a fictional character inspired by William Poole, a real-life gang leader known as "Bill the Butcher." While the film captures the brutality and violence of the era, it takes creative liberties with Bill's character and actions.

Jenny Everdeane

False
Skilled pickpocket and love interest

Jenny Everdeane is a fictional character.

Boss Tweed

Historic
Corrupt politician

Boss Tweed was a real historical figure who controlled Tammany Hall, a powerful political machine in New York City. The film accurately portrays his influence and corruption, as well as his role in the Draft Riots of 1863.

Monk McGinn

False
Loyal henchman

Monk McGinn is a fictional character.

Story Story

The main story is fictional

Not historic

The main story following Amsterdam Vallon seeking revenge is fictional.

Gang warfare

True

The film depicts the violent clashes between rival gangs, such as the 'Natives' (led by Bill the Butcher) and the 'Dead Rabbits' (Irish immigrants).

Setting Setting

Five Points setting

True

The film is set in the Five Points neighborhood of New York City, a notorious slum in the 19th century known for its poverty, crime, and gang violence.

Draft Riots

True

The film depicts the 1863 New York City Draft Riots, a violent uprising against conscription during the Civil War.

Political corruption

True

The film portrays the political corruption and influence of Tammany Hall, a powerful political machine in New York City.

Anti-immigrant sentiment

True

The film accurately depicts the strong anti-immigrant sentiment prevalent in the 19th century, particularly towards Irish immigrants.

Living conditions

Good depiction

The film vividly portrays the squalid and overcrowded living conditions in the Five Points, highlighting the poverty and hardship faced by many residents.

Rise of organized crime

Partly true

The film shows the early stages of organized crime in New York City, but it may exaggerate the influence and power of individual gangs.

Visuals and atmosphere

Good depiction

The film's visuals and atmosphere effectively recreate the gritty and chaotic environment of the Five Points.

 Overall

Historical accuracy

Partly true

While the film is somewhat based on historical events and characters, it takes significant creative liberties and blends fact with fiction.