Historical accuracy of Erin Brockovich

Historical accuracy of Erin Brockovich

Characters
Erin Brockovich
The portrayal is considered highly accurate to the real Erin Brockovich's personality, determination, unconventional methods, and dedication to the Hinkley case, as confirmed by Brockovich herself.
Ed Masry
Based on the real lawyer Ed Masry who hired Brockovich and spearheaded the lawsuit. His initial skepticism, eventual partnership with Erin, and commitment are accurately depicted.
George
Based on Erin's real-life biker boyfriend at the time, Jorge Halaby. His supportive role, including helping with childcare, accurately reflects their relationship during the case.
Donna Jensen
Based on a real Hinkley plaintiff who suffered from illnesses linked to the water contamination and was one of the key residents Erin first connected with.
Charles Embry
Based on the real Charles Embry, a former PG&E worker who provided crucial documents proving the company knew about the dangers of hexavalent chromium and tried to conceal it.
Kurt Potter
Represents the lawyers from the larger firm Masry & Vititoe partnered with (specifically Girardi & Keese, with Thomas Girardi being the lead). Potter is a fictional composite character.
More characters
Theresa Dallavale
Likely a fictional or composite character representing PG&E's initial local legal or community liaisons who interacted dismissively with Erin and the residents.
Pamela Duncan
Likely a fictional or composite character representing the corporate face and legal team of PG&E during the litigation process.
Hinkley Residents (various)
Characters Erin interacts with represent the numerous real families in Hinkley affected by the contamination. While names and specific details might be composites, their health issues and experiences are based on reality.
Scott
Likely a minor fictional character within the law firm setting.
Erin's Children (Matthew, Katie, Beth)
Erin Brockovich is a real mother, and the film accurately portrays her struggles balancing single parenthood with the demands of the Hinkley case.
Story
Erin injured in car accident, loses lawsuit
The real Erin Brockovich was in a car accident and subsequently lost the personal injury lawsuit handled by Ed Masry.
Erin pressures Ed Masry into hiring her
After losing her case, Brockovich insisted Masry give her a job at his law firm, Masry & Vititoe, which he did.
Stumbles upon suspicious medical records in real estate file
While working as a file clerk, Brockovich discovered medical documents mixed into a pro bono real estate case involving PG&E buying homes in Hinkley, triggering her investigation.
PG&E contaminated Hinkley groundwater with hexavalent chromium
The core issue was PG&E's decades-long use of hexavalent chromium (Cr-VI) in cooling towers and its subsequent leakage into the local water supply.
PG&E knowingly misled residents about chromium type/danger
Evidence, including documents revealed by Charles Embry, showed PG&E knew the chromium was toxic Cr-VI (not harmless Cr-III as they claimed) and had concealed information about the contamination.
Erin uses direct, personal approach with residents
Brockovich's success was largely due to her ability to connect with Hinkley residents on a personal level, gain their trust, listen to their stories, and explain complex information clearly.
Memorizes complex case details and plaintiff info
Lacking formal legal training, Brockovich compensated with dedication, memorizing vast amounts of technical data and personal details about the hundreds of plaintiffs.
Collects water samples and documents health issues
A significant part of Erin's work involved visiting Hinkley repeatedly, collecting water samples (sometimes covertly), and meticulously documenting the various illnesses affecting the community.
Initial low settlement offers rejected
PG&E initially made lowball offers to settle individual cases, which were rejected as the full scope of the contamination and the number of affected residents became clear.
Case involves over 600 plaintiffs
The lawsuit ultimately grew to include 634 plaintiffs from Hinkley against PG&E.
Case settled via binding arbitration, not jury trial
Due to its size and complexity, the Hinkley case bypassed a traditional jury trial and was resolved through binding arbitration in 1996.
Settlement amount of $333 million
The case resulted in a $333 million settlement paid by PG&E to the Hinkley plaintiffs, the largest direct-action lawsuit settlement in US history at that time.
Erin receives $2 million bonus from Ed Masry
Ed Masry paid Erin Brockovich a substantial bonus for her pivotal role in the case; reports confirm the amount was around the $2 million depicted in the film.
Balancing single motherhood with demanding case
The film accurately portrays the significant personal challenges Brockovich faced as a single mother juggling childcare, finances, and the immense workload of the PG&E case.
Setting
Depiction of Hinkley, California
The film effectively portrays the small, rural desert community setting of Hinkley in San Bernardino County where the events unfolded. Filming occurred in the area, adding authenticity.
Time Period (Early-Mid 1990s)
Costumes, technology (like early computers, lack of widespread internet/cell phones), cars, and overall atmosphere accurately reflect the early to mid-1990s when the investigation took place.
Masry & Vititoe Law Firm setting
The portrayal of a relatively small, less corporate law firm environment accurately reflects Ed Masry's practice at the time the case began.
PG&E Hinkley Compressor Station
The film includes views of the actual PG&E compressor station in Hinkley, the source of the hexavalent chromium contamination.
Representation of health effects
While avoiding overly graphic medical details, the film accurately conveys the types of illnesses (cancers, respiratory diseases, miscarriages, skin conditions) reported by residents linked to Cr-VI.
Socio-economic status of Hinkley residents
The film accurately portrays Hinkley as a predominantly working-class community, whose residents initially felt powerless against a large corporation like PG&E.