Logo for HistoryGap

Historical accuracy of Belle

Poster

Characters

Largely historic

Story

Largely historic

Setting

Historic

Historical accuracy of: Belle

Characters

Largely historic

Story

Largely historic

Setting

Historic
Poster

Characters

Historic

Dido Elizabeth Belle

Intelligent mixed-race noblewoman

Dido Elizabeth Belle was a real historical figure, the mixed-race daughter of a British naval officer and an enslaved African woman. The film accurately depicts her unique position within English aristocracy and the legal context of the time.

Historic

Lord William Murray, 1st Earl of Mansfield

Dido's uncle

Lord Mansfield was a real historical figure and the Lord Chief Justice who presided over the Zong massacre case. The film accurately portrays his role in the legal and social debates surrounding slavery.

Partly historic

Lady Elizabeth Murray

Kindhearted cousin

Lady Elizabeth Murray was Dido's cousin and companion, and she did live at Kenwood House. The film depicts her relationship with Dido, however, the degree of her social struggle is dramatized.

False

John Davinier

Idealistic vicar's son

John Davinier is a character that represents the abolitionist lawyers of the time. While based on the spirit of the abolitionists, he is somewhat of a composite character.

Historic

Lady Mary Murray

Stern aristocratic aunt

Lady Mary Murray was Lord Mansfield's wife and Dido's great-aunt. The film accurately portrays her role as a figure of aristocratic society and her complex relationship with Dido.

Story

Nobody knows

Dido's artistic talents

The film portrays Dido with artistic talents, but there's no historical evidence to confirm this.

True

Raised by Lord Mansfield

Dido was raised by her great-uncle, William Murray, the Earl of Mansfield, and his wife.

Probably true

Life at Kenwood House

Dido lived at Kenwood House, the Mansfield estate, but the specifics of her daily life and interactions are not fully documented.

True

Legal case of the Zong

The film depicts the Zong massacre, a real incident where enslaved people were thrown overboard from a slave ship for insurance purposes. Lord Mansfield presided over the related legal case.

Partly true

Mansfield's anti-slavery stance

While Mansfield made rulings against slavery, his views were complex and his actions sometimes contradictory. The film may oversimplify his position.

True

Dido's legal status

Dido was born into slavery but was later recognized as a free woman and heiress.

Good depiction

Social constraints

The film portrays the social constraints and prejudices faced by Dido due to her race and illegitimacy.

True

Relationship with John Davinier

Dido married John Davinier, a legal clerk, and they had several children.

Probably true

Dido's influence on Mansfield

While the extent of her influence is unknown, it's plausible that Dido's presence and experiences informed Mansfield's views on slavery.

Nobody knows

Romantic subplot

The film includes a romantic subplot involving Dido and a potential suitor. While there may have been suitors, the specific details are fictionalized.

Average depiction

Family dynamics

The film portrays the complex family dynamics within the Mansfield household, but it may take some creative liberties.

Good depiction

Contrast between cousins

The film highlights the contrasting experiences and social positions of Dido and Elizabeth due to their race.